RECIPE: Simple Ice Cream (plus more summer desserts!)


I make simple desserts.  I like to eat complicated desserts when someone else (like my gourmet sister-in-law) makes them.  (Gluten-free tiramisu for my birthday last year.  Yeah, she’s amazing like that.)  But I try to keep it simple at home.  Despite all the unhealthy additives in the store-bought kind, ice cream was once a simple dessert to make.

As mentioned in my Summer Fun list, we got a new-to-us ice cream maker off of Freecycle and are determined to use it regularly this summer!  So far, we’ve made chocolate with mini chocolate chips, lemon (with fresh zest and juice), and then back to chocolate again, because you can’t go wrong with chocolate. And my son has requested pineapple with mint from our yard for our next experiment.  Creative, no?  We watch a lot of cooking shows…


First, I use full fat coconut milk instead of cream because I was spoiled by the Amish and their reasonably priced raw cream when I lived on the east coast.  It was actually cream-colored (unlike the store-bought) and spoonably thick.  I would get a quart at a time and make whipped cream with real maple syrup.  It was incredible.  I’m actually getting sad…

You can get raw cream in California, but it costs a million dollars (because milk production is more difficult in drier areas than in the lush Pennsylvania countryside) and I don’t have a million dollars.  And most cream is ultra-pasteurized which is not good.  My previously mentioned gourmet sister-in-law has told me about a couple of brands that are only pasteurized, but I’m still working through my cream issues (Cream Snob?) and am happy with the coconut milk for now.

Next, I was determined to find an ice cream recipe base that I didn’t have to heat.  Remember, I want simple.  No heat, means one less thing to clean and I need less things to clean.  The Minimalist Baker has a dairy-free green tea version, then there’s this fun coffee flavor, can’t wait to try Laura’s pistachio ice cream, and I finally found my inspiration from the Nourishing Gourmet’s chocolate coconut milk ice cream.

Then, of course, I began the unique art of never following the recipe exactly.  I used raw cacao powder instead of cocoa powder, substituted a combination of maple syrup and liquid stevia for the agave syrup. And then Holistic Squid saved me some major research by figuring out how to keep it from refreezing into a rockadd salt and alcohol (or more vanilla extract that’s in an alcohol base).

So the final gathering of ingredients looks something like this:


oops – forgot the sea salt!


2 cans of full fat coconut milk (preferably BPA-free brands)

2/3 – 3/4 cup flavoring (cacao/cocoa powder, lemon juice/zest, peaches, etc.)

1/3 cup real maple syrup (or honey would work too)

2 tablespoons vanilla extract (in alcohol base)

1/2 teaspoon of sea salt

Blend all the ingredients in your Vita-Mix (put it on your wish list!), food processor (a must-have in the kitchen) or stick blender (got mine off of Freecycle!)  Taste and adjust accordingly.  (I use stevia to sweeten.)  Dump into your ice cream maker and follow its instructions.  


My lovely ice cream churning assistant…

If you have any ice cream left, shame on you.  But you could redeem yourself and make some gluten-free ice cream sandwiches.  (Not a simple recipe by any stretch, but perhaps my sister-in-law is reading…)

And what if you don’t have an ice cream maker?  

First, keep checking Freecycle or Craigslist.  I’ve heard you can put it in a flat dish with a lid, but ice cream makers are more fun.

Second use your food processor to make a cultured banana swirl or instant raspberry ice cream.

Or invest in popsicle molds to make banana almond butter pops, one of these 100+ popsicle recipes, or throw your leftover smoothies in for an easily accessible summer treat.

Whatever you make, enjoy your summer and some cool sweet treats!

What’s your favorite recipe for a frozen summer treat?

Related Posts:  More simple desserts – Chocolate Deliciousness and Choc-amole’!

Featured at:  Make Your Own! Mondays


6 thoughts on “RECIPE: Simple Ice Cream (plus more summer desserts!)

  1. Looks good! Just in time for summer. My boys and I are excited to try them. I pinned them on Pinterest. Hope that’s ok?

  2. I am going to get my ice cream maker into the freezer tonight! I’ve been eating coconut ice cream already made lately from TJs and food coop, but would like to make my own. If it is on sale it is worth it for me to buy. If not, I’ll make it. II will also add a tablespoon or less of decaf instant coffee powder from TJs to make a rich coffee chocolate flavor.

  3. Good call on chocolate and coffee TOGETHER, Jenna! But beware of the additives and thickeners that they even put in the coconut ice creams. They may taste amazing, but many of those ingredients are starting to get bad press…

  4. Pingback: Coconut (Kefir) Soda | Shesourceful

  5. I’ve never invested in an ice cream maker. Your homemade ice cream recipes look so good. I do make some frozen concoctions in my Vitamix. It’s not quite ice cream, but non the less it’s still good.

  6. Yeah, it took me a while to invest in an ice cream maker as well. But when it’s free, it doesn’t feel like too much of an investment! We’ve tried the Vitamix ice cream as well, but I find it difficult to get everything out of the bottom and a lot seems to go to waste. Feel free to share your favorite ice cream recipe!

    On Wed, Jun 19, 2013 at 6:51 PM, Shesourceful

What say you?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s